AI Search · 2026-11-17

Questions to Ask Before Hiring a GEO Agency

Ask how they measure AI visibility, what they will not promise, what the work involves and what you own if you leave. Here is the checklist.

Short answer: Before you hire a GEO (generative engine optimisation) agency, ask four kinds of question: how they measure AI visibility, what they will and will not promise, what the work actually involves, and what you keep if you leave. A good agency answers with a fixed set of tracked prompts, a baseline before any work starts, a plain statement that nobody can guarantee AI citations, and a contract you can exit. Vague answers on any of these are the warning sign, not the price.

This checklist is for founders and marketing leads in the US, UK, Europe, Australia and the Gulf who are comparing agencies that sell GEO, AEO or "AI search" services.

Why hiring for GEO is harder than hiring for SEO

With classic SEO you can agree on the scoreboard: rankings, clicks and leads, mostly visible in Google Search Console. AI answers are different. ChatGPT, Perplexity, Gemini, Copilot and Google's AI Overviews generate a fresh answer each time, results vary by wording and location, and there is no public ranking to point at.

That gap invites overselling. Some agencies promise guaranteed citations within weeks; others say plainly they cannot control what a model says. Google itself takes a sober line. Its documentation on AI features and your website says: "There are no additional requirements to appear in AI Overviews or AI Mode, nor other special optimizations necessary." Its May 2026 guide went further, describing optimising for generative AI search as "still SEO" (Search Engine Journal).

So the questions below test whether an agency does the fundamentals that make you citable, and measures them honestly.

The checklist: 14 questions, good answers and red flags

# Question to ask A good answer sounds like Red flag
1 How will you measure our AI visibility? A fixed list of prompts, named engines, a set frequency, the same method every month "We'll send screenshots when we get mentioned"
2 Can we see a sample report? A real anonymised report with mention rate, citations and competitors Only a sales deck
3 What is our baseline today? Measured in the first weeks, before any changes No baseline, so any result looks like progress
4 Can you guarantee we will be cited? No, and an explanation of what they can influence A guarantee with no written terms
5 Which engines do you track, and why those? Matched to where your buyers search, in your markets "All of them" with no detail
6 What will you actually change on our site? Crawl access, page structure, answers, schema where it helps, entity facts Only "AI optimised content"
7 How do you check crawlers can reach us? Robots.txt, CDN and firewall checks for Googlebot and AI search bots Never mentioned
8 What happens off our site? Reviews, directories, digital PR and mentions on sources AI tools already cite Paid link schemes
9 How does this connect to leads or revenue? AI referral traffic in analytics, enquiries, branded search trends Visibility only, forever
10 What is your experience in our market? Examples in your country, language and regulation (GDPR for EU and UK buyers) One template for every country
11 Who does the work, and where? A named role structure and how time zones and handovers work Unclear subcontracting
12 What is the contract length and notice period? Clear minimum term, or a paid pilot first Long lock in before any baseline
13 What do we own if we leave? Your content, your accounts, your tracking data and prompt list Reports and tools that disappear with them
14 When would you tell us GEO is not worth it for us? A real answer, with examples "It's right for everyone"

Questions 1 to 4 do most of the filtering. If an agency cannot explain its measurement plainly, nothing else matters.

Questions about measurement: what good reporting looks like

Ask for the method, not just the dashboard. A credible setup includes:

  1. A written prompt set. Twenty to a few hundred questions your buyers really ask, grouped by topic and stage, agreed with you and kept stable so month to month comparisons mean something.
  2. Named engines and a schedule. For example ChatGPT, Perplexity, Gemini, Copilot and Google AI Overviews, checked weekly or monthly, with location and language stated.
  3. Clear metrics. How often you are mentioned, how often you are cited with a link, which pages are cited, and how you compare with three to five named competitors.
  4. First party data alongside it. Google says traffic from AI features is included in the overall Search Console Performance report under the "Web" search type (Google), so it will not appear as a separate line. Bing Webmaster Tools has added an AI Performance report covering citations in Copilot (Search Engine Land). A good agency uses both, plus AI referral traffic in your analytics.

Because answers vary between runs, one screenshot of a win proves very little. To see what a starter version looks like, our free AI visibility tracker writes a buyer prompt set from a short description of your business and scores your mention rate, citation rate and share of voice, so you can bring your own baseline to every agency call.

Questions about the work itself

Ask the agency to walk you through its first 90 days. The answer should cover three layers.

Access. Can search and AI crawlers reach your pages? OpenAI says sites that block OAI-SearchBot will not appear in ChatGPT search answers, while GPTBot, its training crawler, can be blocked separately (OpenAI). Our guide to robots.txt for AI crawlers explains the split, and our free AI robots.txt generator writes a safe file. Bot protection on your CDN can also block crawlers your robots.txt allows; see is your CDN blocking Google and AI search.

Content. Pages that answer real buyer questions directly, with clear headings, facts, comparisons and FAQs, plus consistent facts about who you are, where you operate and what you sell. Our guide to getting cited by AI search covers this checklist in detail.

Reputation. AI tools lean on what other sites say about you: reviews, directories, industry publications and comparisons. Ignoring off site signals is half a job.

If the plan leans on a single trick, such as an llms.txt file or a special schema type, push back. Google's same documentation says you do not need new machine readable files, AI text files or special markup to appear in its AI features. Such files are extras, not a strategy.

Questions about contract, price and ownership

Pricing for GEO varies widely by market and scope, and some agencies now publish their prices while many do not. Rather than comparing headline fees, compare what each fee buys:

  • Scope per month. How many pages, prompts, outreach placements or technical fixes are included?
  • Term and exit. Is there a minimum term? Many buyers prefer a short paid pilot or audit first, then a monthly retainer once a baseline exists.
  • Ownership. Content, analytics properties, tracking tool accounts and the prompt list should belong to you or be handed over on exit.
  • Data and compliance. If the agency will access personal data in your CRM or analytics, EU and UK buyers will need a data processing agreement under GDPR.

Google's long standing advice on hiring an SEO still applies here: no one can guarantee a top ranking, and you should be wary of anyone claiming a special relationship with a search engine. The same goes for AI assistants.

When you do not need a GEO agency

You may not need a specialist yet if:

  • your site has basic SEO problems (slow pages, missing pages for core services, crawl errors), because those block AI visibility too;
  • you sell mainly through referrals in a small niche and buyers rarely search;
  • you have no proof to point at yet: reviews, case studies or named clients often move the needle more than more content.

In those cases, fix the foundations first or hire for SEO with GEO included.

Key takeaways

  • Ask for the measurement method first: a fixed prompt set, named engines, a baseline and a sample report.
  • Treat guarantees of AI citations as a red flag unless the terms are written down and make sense.
  • Good GEO work covers access, content and reputation, not one trick or file.
  • Compare scope, term, exit and ownership, not just the monthly fee.
  • If your SEO foundations are weak, fix those before paying for AI search on its own.

FAQ

Can a GEO agency guarantee my brand will appear in ChatGPT?

No one controls what ChatGPT, Gemini or Perplexity says, so treat a guarantee of citations with caution unless its terms are written down. An agency can improve what makes you easier to cite: crawl access, clear answers, consistent facts and mentions on trusted sites.

How long before GEO work shows results?

It depends on your starting point and how competitive the questions are. Technical fixes such as unblocking crawlers can matter quickly, while content and reputation work builds over months. A good agency reports against a baseline on a fixed schedule rather than promising a date.

Is GEO different from SEO, or the same thing?

Google describes optimising for its generative AI features as still SEO, and the fundamentals overlap heavily: indexable pages, helpful content and a strong reputation. The differences are in measurement (prompts and citations instead of only rankings) and in covering assistants beyond Google. Many buyers are better served by one team doing both.

What should a GEO report include each month?

At minimum: the prompts and engines checked, mention and citation rates against the baseline, which pages were cited, how named competitors compare and the work done. It should also show Search Console data and AI referral traffic from your analytics.

Comparing agencies for AI search, or want a baseline of how visible you are in AI answers today? Talk to our SEO and AI search team.